Skip to main content Skip to footer

Condo Chronicles: Navigating Condominium Fenestration Replacement and Restoration Projects

February 21, 2025

Navigating Condominium Fenestration Replacement and Restoration Projects

 

IN THE EVER-EVOLVING world of architectural
design and construction, condominium
fenestration replacement and restoration
projects are complex endeavors that require
strategic planning, expert execution,
and
an understanding of the intricate dynamics
at play within a condominium complex.
Challenges arise from the blend of shared
ownership, communal living, and diverse
stakeholder interests characteristic of
condominium communities. The challenges
and considerations presented in this
article apply most directly to large tower
or mid-rise condominium complexes;
however, many points are also relevant for
low-rise, multifamily residences and smaller
condominium complexes.
Fenestration, which encompasses windows,
doors, and their related components, plays
a critical role in any building’s performance,
energy efficiency, functionality, and aesthetic
appeal. Fenestrations are a distinctive part of
the building enclosure, but, unlike the rest of
the building enclosure, they may be owned
by individual unit owners rather than being
common property owned by the condominium
association.
For this reason, wholesale,
property-wide replacement or restoration
of fenestration is unusual in condominium
complexes compared to single-owner residential
buildings. Fenestration ownership structures
may vary between condominium associations,
and it is important for designers to understand
who carries financial responsibility.
Condominium associations or individual unit
owners may find that fenestration replacement
or restoration is necessary to resolve water
leakage, air leakage, thermal discomfort,
operability issues, and/or structural issues.
In our experience, wholesale fenestration
replacement is only mandated across an entire
building or complex when the issues with the
existing fenestrations are so severe that they
Condo Chronicles:
Navigating Condominium
Fenestration Replacement
and Restoration Projects
Feature
By Christopher N. Grey, PE; Kelsey A. Dunn,
PE; and Megan L. Wilson, PE
are causing deterioration of adjacent building
components or pose a safety concern, such
as damage to the exterior framed structural
framing components. Smaller, voluntary
replacement or restoration projects
that are
executed by individual owners opting into the
project are more common.
In this article, we delve into the complexities
of fenestration replacement and restoration
in condominiums from the perspective
of
design professionals who collaborate with
condominium clients and property managers.
We focus primarily on describing the common
challenges associated with these types of
projects, including logistical hurdles, financial
implications, ownership responsibilities,
adherence to building codes, performance
requirements, and the potential impact of the
projects
on residents’ daily lives. We aim to
provide the various condominium complex
stakeholders with a catalog of considerations
for executing condominium fenestration
projects, ensuring that they are well equipped to
navigate the multifaceted challenges and opportunities
presented by these intricate endeavors,
and provide other design professionals with
guidelines for their fenestration projects.
COMMON RELATIONSHIPS
AND RESPONSIBILITIES
In a condominium complex, several parties play
crucial roles in making decisions and executing
fenestration replacement or restoration projects.
Understanding the relationships among these
Interface articles may cite trade, brand,
or product names to specify or describe
adequately materials, experimental
procedures, and/or equipment. In no
case does such identification imply
recommendation or endorsement by
the International Institute of Building
Enclosure Consultants (IIBEC).
This paper was presented at the 2024 IIBEC
International Convention and Trade Show.
©2025 International Institute of Building Enclosure 16 • IIBEC Interface Consultants (IIBEC) February 2025
parties is essential for design professionals
and contractors
involved in such projects. The
following is a summary of the stakeholders and
their roles and responsibilities as they relate to
the fenestration systems.
Condominium Association
A condominium association is a legal entity that
is governed by a board of trustees or directors
(elected unit owners), which acts on behalf of all
unit owners and is responsible
for managing and
maintaining the common/shared elements of the
condominium complex. The responsibilities of a
condominium association can vary depending
on the specific bylaws and regulations
of the
condominium, as well as the state or local laws
that govern condominiums.
The association is responsible for ensuring that
any fenestration work executed at the property
complies with the bylaws and regulations of
the condominium. The association can require
a unit owner to replace or make repairs to the
unit’s fenestration
systems if those systems
are affecting common area elements or the
building structure. The association
can also
approve a defined procedure mandating certain
requirements or products/assemblies
for work
executed by individual unit owners.
Unit Owners
Individual unit owners hold a stake in the
condominium and contribute financially to the
condominium association through monthly
dues and other assessments. They have a vested
interest in the maintenance and improvement of
common elements,
as these affect the value and
livability of their units.
Unit owners may have differing opinions on
the timing and scope of fenestration projects,
which can lead to discussions or conflicts within
the community. Unit owners commonly
confuse
what are considered common elements (owned
by the association) and unit owner elements
(owned by the individual unit owners). Even
when unit owners are financially responsible
for their unit’s fenestration (as is the case in
most condominiums), they are required to
comply with any regulations approved by
the association.
Property Manager
In professionally managed condominiums,
the property manager is typically hired by the
association to oversee day-to-day operations,
including maintenance and repair projects, and
act as a liaison between the association, unit
owners, and external contractors and professionals.
The responsibilities of a property manager
can vary depending on the condominium
association. In some cases, a condominium may
not have a property manager, and the association
may perform the role of property manager.
Property managers often directly engage with
and coordinate the work of design professionals,
such as architects and engineers, on behalf of
the condominium association to assess, plan,
and execute fenestration
projects. Property
managers may act as the association representative
during fenestration projects and assist
with coordinating the project work with the
individual unit owners.
Design Professionals
Design professionals (engineers and architects)
are responsible for assessing the existing
fenestration systems, determining the
scope of work required, providing design
recommendations, and specifying systems.
They are engaged by and collaborate closely
with the property manager and condominium
association to ensure that the project aligns
with the condominium’s requirements, goals,
and budget.
Design professionals are responsible for
selecting or designing fenestration
systems that
comply with the technical project requirements,
including aesthetic design, structural integrity,
safety and performance requirements, and
compliance with building codes. Design
professionals must carefully assess the existing
conditions, propose appropriate solutions,
and oversee the project to minimize risks and
potential liabilities for all involved stakeholders.
Contractors
Contractors are responsible for managing the
construction process, which includes schedules,
budgets, permits and city approvals, site
management, safety, and managing
work.
They are responsible for ensuring that all work,
material, and installation meet or exceed the
quality standards and specifications outlined in
the contract and comply with building codes and
industry standards. Contractors provide guarantees
that cover defects in materials and quality
of work for a specified duration.
Contractors are responsible for coordinating
the various trades as required to execute a
fenestration replacement or repair project,
including demolition, waterproofing, cladding,
glazing, and interior finish subcontractors.
Contractors need to work closely with the
property managers
and unit owners to execute
the work to their satisfaction.
Fenestration Product Manufacturers
Fenestration product manufacturers
are
responsible for fabricating and providing
products that meet or exceed industry
standards and project-specific requirements.
Manufacturers need to obtain and maintain
relevant certifications and documentation
to demonstrate compliance with industry
standards, building codes, and regulations.
They offer product warranties that cover
defects in materials or quality of work for a
specified duration.
Fenestration manufacturers are responsible
for fabricating fenestration
systems that
meet or exceed industry standards and the
project specification requirements dictated
by the project’s design professionals.
The
manufacturers often offer technical support
and assistance to design professionals and
contractors during the fenestration design and
installation process.

RESTORATION VERSUS
REPLACEMENT

The first step in executing a fenestration
project
is for the design professional to evaluate existing
conditions and help the property manager,
unit owners, and condominium
association
determine the scope of work. The decision
of whether to restore or replace existing
fenestration can be difficult
because several
factors must be considered. The opportunities
to improve air, water, structural, or operability
performance of existing fenestrations may be
too limited to provide the benefits sought by the
owners, and the overall project cost of restoring
fenestration can be similar to the cost of
replacement. It can be difficult to justify the cost
of restoring existing fenestration if restoration
will achieve only marginal performance
improvement. However, restoration may be
dictated by historic
preservation requirements
or be a jurisdictional requirement for another
reason. Restoration may also be appropriate if
the condominium intends to perform an opt-in
project, where the condominium association
oversees a fenestration project that multiple
unit owners opt in to as opposed to mandating a
complex-
wide project and does not want changes
to select fenestration to alter the aesthetics of
the building.
Design professionals should carefully
review the relative feasibility, costs, and
benefits of replacement
and restoration
projects and discuss the options with the
project stakeholders before a condominium
decides whether to proceed with a fenestration
restoration
or replacement project. Note
that the issues discussed in the “Design- and
Construction-Phase Considerations” section
of this article apply to both restoration and
replacement projects.
February 2025 IIBEC Interface • 17
RESTORATION-SPECIFIC
CONSIDERATIONS
Performance
Restoration is typically constrained by the design
of the existing fenestration,
and therefore it
offers limited opportunities to improve the air,
water, and thermal performance of existing
fenestration assemblies. The existing frames
may be able to accommodate insulated glass
units (IGUs). However, the increase in overall
thermal performance will be minimal if the
existing framing members are not thermally
broken. In some cases, the configuration of
existing frames that use monolithic glass cannot
readily accept IGUs and needs to be modified.
When fenestration is operable, new gaskets and
hardware can be installed around the operable
sashes to achieve improved air infiltration
resistance and operability. However, the gaskets
will often need to be adhered and will remain
maintenance
items. Storm windows can be
installed outboard or inboard of the existing
windows to provide some improvement to the
thermal performance and air infiltration, thus
improving occupant comfort (Fig. 1). However,
storm windows can have a negative impact on
the ease of operation, ventilation, and aesthetics.
Concealed Structural Deterioration
Existing interior and exterior finishes can conceal
significant structural deterioration, and the
true condition of existing steel or wood window
frames will not be known until the finishes,
glazing, and/or coatings are removed (Fig. 2a
and 2b). This is primarily
an issue with older
wood and steel fenestrations.
Because it is difficult to estimate the
extent of deterioration until the windows
Figure 1. Storm windows installed at localized fenestration of a condominium building. Yellow
arrow indicates a location with a storm window; red arrow indicates a location without a
storm window.
Figure 2a. Coating and glazing putty conceal corrosion of steel mullions. Figure 2b. Coating removal reveals extensive corrosion of steel mullions.
18 • IIBEC Interface February 2025
are disassembled and the existing finishes
are removed, the design professional will be
challenged
to forecast project costs and advise
clients about whether to pursue fenestration
repairs or replacement. If there is severe
deterioration
in isolated locations, isolated
framing members may need to be removed
and replaced or reinforced, but if there is
widespread deterioration,
the scope (and cost)
of the repair/replacement project will be much
more extensive.
Contractor Interest/Availability
Window restoration is specialized construction
that requires artisan contractors with skilled
craftspeople to perform the repairs. Successful
execution of a fenestration restoration project
is dependent on the availability
of skilled
contractors willing to reglaze, reconfigure, and
restore existing fenestration systems. Design
professionals should assist the association
in
vetting qualified contractors while compiling a
bid list. On past projects, we have found that few
glazing contractors are qualified to do this type
of restoration work, and even fewer are willing
to undertake repair of existing fenestration and
to provide warranties, especially for one-off
work. This work may have more perceived risk
than replacement with a fully integrated system,
and it may result in higher construction costs
than a replacement project. It is critical that the
design professional educate the condominium
association about these considerations
and implications prior to the association
determining whether to perform a restoration or
replacement project.
Cost
Unit owners and condominium associations
may assume that restoring existing fenestration
is less costly than replacement. However, the
cost of restoration can depend heavily on the
extent of the restoration and the expertise
of the contractors performing the work.
Depending on these factors, the overall cost of
restoration may be less than, comparable to, or
even more than the cost of replacing
existing
fenestrations with new ones. The comparative
cost of restoration versus replacement is often
dependent on the type of replacement window
that is being proposed. If the overall project cost
to restore windows is less than or comparable
to replacement, restoration may still be less
cost-effective over the long term, as the service
life of restored fenestration is usually not as
long as that of new fenestration.
To assist the
condominium association with determining
how to proceed, the design professional should
provide approximate cost-per-square-foot
estimates and estimated service life for both
restoration and several replacement options
for consideration.
Expectations
It is difficult to predict the performance
of
restored fenestrations, as they will not be rated
assemblies that meet rigorous water penetration
and air infiltration field-testing standards. We
generally recommend using mock-ups to assess
the proposed restoration procedures, testing the
mock-ups for performance in general accordance
with ASTM E1105 (Standard Test Method for Field
Determination of Water Penetration of Installed
Exterior Windows, Skylights, Doors, and Curtain
Walls, by Uniform or Cyclic Static Air Pressure
Difference)1 and ASTM E783 (Standard Test
Method for Field Measurement of Air Leakage
Through Installation Exterior Windows and
Doors),2 and comparing the testing results to
the expected performance of new fenestrations.
However, this phase is often not performed
at
condominiums because it adds to the project
cost, can be disruptive for owners, and extends
the overall project schedule. It is critical
that
all owners who participate in a restoration
project understand the limitations of restoration
and that the project may not fully restore
functionality, alleviate occupant discomfort,
improve energy efficiency, or address water
leakage issues over the long term. Additionally,
owners should understand that restored
fenestrations
may require more frequent
maintenance than new fenestration assemblies,
depending on the extent of surface preparation
performed and quality of new coatings on
existing
windows that require recoating.
REPLACEMENT-SPECIFIC
CONSIDERATIONS
Existing Profiles and Sight Lines
Some existing types of fenestration, especially
older, non-thermally-broken
steel- or
wood-framed units, have narrow profiles that
can only be achieved by replacing the units
with similar products that match the original
profile. Replacement with more affordable
standard fenestration
products, such as
aluminum- or composite-framed systems, can
result in increased sight lines. In many cases,
installing alternate fenestration products to
improve performance can also affect building
aesthetics. Following an opt-in replacement
project, the sight lines would vary between
the new and existing fenestrations (Fig. 3).
Therefore, if most owners in a condominium do
Figure 3. Sight lines at the replacement
fenestration (indicated with the arrow) are thicker than
existing fenestration profile next to it.
February 2025 IIBEC Interface • 19
not support a proposed fenestration replacement
project where sight lines would be increased,
the condominium may choose to perform an
opt-in restoration project in lieu of an opt-in
fenestration replacement project to avoid varied
fenestration sight lines around the building.
Code Requirements
Fenestration replacement projects are typically
considered by code officials
as Level 1 Alterations
under the International Existing Building
Code3 and must meet current International
Energy Conservation Code (IECC)4 prescriptive
requirements. In several states, including
Massachusetts, the 2021 version of the IECC
has been adopted with additional state-specific
amendments that include more stringent
U-value requirements.
These new U-value requirements can be
difficult to meet with standard thermally broken
aluminum-framed fenestration. Many of the
aluminum-framed assemblies that we would
typically specify for larger mid- to high-rise
condominium
fenestration replacement projects
cannot meet the new U-value requirements,
even with triple glazing and multiple e-coatings.
The inability to meet code requirements is
more pronounced if the building has smaller
fenestration units, as it is difficult for smaller
units (which have low glazing-to-frame ratios)
to meet U-value requirements. Adding triple
glazing may be cost prohibitive for owners
and may have structural implications due
to the increased weight of glazing, leading
the condominium
to instead choose vinyl or
aluminum-clad wood replacement fenestration
products, which have better thermal
performance than aluminum-framed products.
Filing for an energy code variance through
the authority having jurisdiction is possible;
however, the feasibility of this option depends
on the jurisdiction,
and our experience is that
most local jurisdictions will not consider higher
cost to unit owners as a reason to waive energy
code requirements.
Interior Finish Impacts
During fenestration replacement projects,
interior finishes may be affected if the new
frames are deeper than the existing frames or if
the interior finishes need to be removed to install
a continuous interior air seal between the new
frame and the rough opening. Removing and
replacing interior finishes in condominium units
can be challenging, as the existing conditions
can vary by unit, and unit owners have differing
expectations
of modifications inside their homes.
If owners have added decorative
trim, wood
stools, wainscoting, shades, or other intricate
interior finishes, removal and replacement is
not as simple as cutting and patching drywall.
It can be difficult for contractors to price this
work, and it is time-consuming to document
and catalog all existing conditions for contractor
pricing. To avoid misaligned
expectations, it is
critical that both the contractor and the owners
acknowledge who is responsible for performing
and paying for interior finish replacement and
painting. In our experience, it is best practice
to limit the impact of a fenestration project on
interior finishes as much as possible. If the new
frames are wider than the existing frames, we
recommend maintaining the interior plane of the
existing fenestration and accommodating the
added depth on the exterior side of the opening.
However, that option is not always possible,
depending on the construction
of the exterior
wall assembly and the alignment between the
new frame and existing cladding.
DESIGN- AND
CONSTRUCTION-PHASE
CONSIDERATIONS
Once the scope of work is defined, the
next steps of the project are design and
construction. Successful fenestration projects
in a condominium
complex require effective
communication and collaboration among the
design professionals, property managers,
condominium association, and fenestration
suppliers
to ensure that the project meets
quality, safety, and budgetary goals while
addressing the needs and concerns of unit
owners and the condominium association.
The considerations identified in the following
sections should be reviewed and discussed by
the project team throughout the design and
construction phases.
Failure Mechanism
A fenestration project is commonly precipitated
by performance failure of the fenestration
units. Types of performance failure include
water penetration or air leakage to the interior,
condensation within IGUs, operability issues, or
occupant discomfort.
It is critical that the failure
mechanisms are identified and the contributing
factors are thoroughly diagnosed so that they
can be addressed by the fenestration project.
If adjacent construction or interior conditions
contribute to the failure, a fenestration
replacement or restoration
project will need to
address these contributing factors; otherwise,
the performance failures may continue once the
project is complete.
One common example is water leakage
through perimeter conditions
(Fig. 4 and 5).
Owners may observe active water leakage or
deteriorated interior finishes around an existing
fenestration and assume that replacing the
fenestration will address water-intrusion issues.
However, the fenestration perimeter
flashings
may not be properly integrated with the adjacent
Figure 4. Water leakage at interior appears at window head; however, the leakage path is
through exterior masonry wall above.
20 • IIBEC Interface February 2025
exterior wall assemblies. If the fenestration is
restored or replaced but the perimeter
flashings
are not modified to properly integrate with the
adjacent exterior wall assemblies, it is likely that
water leakage will continue after the replacement
window is installed.
Execution Method and Cost
Implications
It is important to determine how the project will
be executed early in the design phase. Once
the design professional has been engaged
and has determined the required scope of
work, the project team must determine how to
execute the project. The three most common
ways to execute fenestration replacement or
restoration are a wholesale building/complex
project, a multiunit opt-in project, and a
single-unit/one-off project. In the following
sections, we discuss considerations for each
execution method.
Wholesale Building/Complex
Project
Over the long term, the most economical
option for conducting a fenestration restoration
project is to restore or replace all fenestration
for the building/complex at once. This approach
takes advantage of economy of scale, and the
total cost per fenestration (including material,
labor, and access costs) is generally lower than
other execution options. Many manufacturers
will reduce the price per fenestration if the
total quantity of units ordered is above a
certain threshold specific to the manufacturer.
Contractor overhead costs, front-end costs, and
design professional
fees are also spread among
owners from the entire condominium complex.
Performing replacement or restoration for the
entire complex also ensures that the fenestration
life cycles of all units are aligned, which makes
future maintenance and replacement easier
to track.
However, performing a wholesale project can
be politically and legally challenging, especially
when unit owners own the fenestration within
their units, as it is unlikely that all owners will
want to proceed with a fenestration project
simultaneously. Executing a mandatory
fenestration
project could require changing
condominium documents so that the association
assumes ownership of the fenestration, passing a
required quorum vote, or pressuring unit owners
to pay for work that they may not be willing or
able to pay for.
In a wholesale project, the design professional
is engaged to develop construction documents
for the entire building or complex, with the
assumption that the work will be completed
at once. Furthermore, when a project is
large and costs are shared among the unit
owners, it may be cost-effective to engage the
design professional to perform construction
administration during the construction phase.
The design professional can provide responses
to contractors’ requests for information
and
perform quality assurance reviews, which
generally improve the overall quality of the final
installation and limit risk to the condominium
association. Additionally, compared with a
small project, a large, wholesale
project will
generally be more likely to attract experienced
contractors,
increasing the odds for success on
complex projects.
Multiunit Opt-In Projects
Multiunit opt-in fenestration projects are hybrids
between wholesale and one-off projects. A
multiunit execution
strategy provides some of
the economy of scale and cost-sharing benefits
provided by a wholesale project without
the complication of forcing all unit owners
to participate in the project. In many cases,
the design professional’s fees are covered by
the condominium association, as the design
documents can also serve as a basis for future
one-off fenestration
projects. Because the costs
are shared among multiple owners, it may be
affordable to engage the design professional
to perform limited construction administration
and quality assurance reviews during the
construction phase.
Single-Unit/One-Off Projects
Performing a fenestration replacement or
restoration project at a single unit will be the
most financially burdensome option for that
unit’s owner and will likely have less design
professional involvement and oversight than
a wholesale or multiunit project. If a single
unit owner decides to replace or restore the
fenestration within their unit independently, they
will likely engage a contractor directly. Unless
the association has a predetermined
process in
place that provides owners direction on how to
replace or restore fenestration, the unit owner
in this scenario will rely on the contractor that
they hire to act as the design professional. The
quality of the final installation will thus be highly
dependent on the skill and knowledge of the
contractor. In our experience, a one-off fenestration
project will attract a residential contractor,
who may have limited experience performing
fenestration restoration or replacement under
the direction of a design professional. If a unit
owner opts to perform a fenestration
project on
their own, there is a risk that the project will not
address the underlying cause of performance
failure. For example, a single-unit fenestration
replacement will likely not involve exterior access
or removal of exterior wall components. The
perimeter conditions would likely be limited to
interior-installed sealant, which may not provide
a continuous seal to the water-resistive barrier
within the exterior wall assembly, depending
Figure 5. Interior finish damage beneath fenestration was caused by water accumulating
between the storm window and the original fenestration unit.
February 2025 IIBEC Interface • 21
on the type of exterior
wall assembly (Fig. 6). If
water leakage was occurring through the tie-in
between the existing fenestration
and exterior
wall, replacing the fenestration with a new
fenestration without providing an improved
tie-in to the exterior wall will not address the
underlying cause of the leakage, and it is likely
that leakage will recur.
The best method for executing one-off
fenestration projects is to engage a design
professional to develop construction
documents for the entire complex with the
assumption that fenestration will be replaced
on a one-off or as-needed basis. Such
documents include standard replacement
or restoration details and a specification
package listing recommended materials and
manufacturers. Research regarding product
availability is required, as many manufacturers
will not provide products in very limited
quantities. A challenge with this execution
method is that it is difficult to ensure that the
work is completed per the design documents
without design professional involvement
during construction. One-off replacements
significantly increase liability risk for design
professionals, as they have less control over the
final installation.
Access
Fenestration projects typically require
exterior access to the building. Condominium
associations may request that the project be
completed
with interior-only access, but that
approach may limit the contractor’s
ability
to provide adequate tie-ins to adjacent wall
construction and dictate how much of the
fenestration
can be assembled in a factory
instead of on site. While field-fabricating
portions of fenestration offers flexibility,
fabricating in the field increases the risk of
issues with the quality of work; can increase
overall cost because it requires increased field
labor; increases the risk of weather-related
delays; and can extend overall construction
schedules. Fenestration systems that are
factory built offer greater quality control,
improved consistency between products, ideal
environmental conditions for sensitive material
installation, and warranties.
Interior-only access can also pose safety
risks when fenestration is removed or replaced.
Exterior access can significantly increase project
costs, as work will require either an aerial lift
rental and associated street permits, pipe
staging or scaffolding, or swing staging. Exterior
access is typically more affordable for larger
projects because the access costs are spread
among more units.
Occupant Disruption
Any fenestration project will affect the unit
occupants while work is being completed
within their living spaces. The area surrounding
the fenestration will likely be isolated from the
remainder of the unit for the duration of the
project, altering the amount of natural light
and living space within the unit. If scaffolding
or pipe staging is required to perform the
work, views from units will be obscured, and
occupants will be near the work zone. While
increasing the number of fenestration units
included in the project scope offers cost
efficiencies, it may increase the duration of
tenant disruption and discomfort. Once a
construction schedule is determined, it is
vital to communicate with the condominium
association, unit owners, and tenants to ensure
that the expectations regarding timelines and
disruptions are clear.
CONCLUSION
When fenestrations require replacement
or restoration, the execution of the project
will require careful consideration and
planning. Successful fenestration projects
in a condominium building/complex require
effective communication and collaboration
among all stakeholders. Design professionals,
contractors, property managers, and fenestration
suppliers must work together to ensure
that the project meets quality, safety, and
budgetary goals while addressing the
needs and concerns of unit owners and the
condominium association. Careful planning,
documentation, and risk management are
essential to minimize potential liabilities
and disputes.
Considering the intricate nature of executing
fenestration work within condominium
buildings/complexes, condominium
associations should be proactively equipped
to address fenestration failures and provide
guidance to unit owners who wish to replace
or restore their fenestration on a one-off basis.
The best strategy is to proactively provide
association-
approved contract documents
for fenestration replacement or restoration
and establish a well-defined
procedure that
delineates for individual unit owners the
criteria governing fenestration replacement
and restoration. This strategy is critical, as in
the absence of clear guidelines, unit owners
could install fenestration products that may
not align with the preferences of various
stakeholders or use installation procedures
that adversely affect other parts of the building
enclosure. Even if there is no immediate need
for wholesale or large-scale fenestration
replacement or restoration, it is prudent for
condominium associations
to forecast potential
future projects and factor that forecast into their
financial planning.
Figure 6. One-off fenestration replacement where the perimeter air/water barrier is limited
to sealant.
22 • IIBEC Interface February 2025
REFERENCES
1. ASTM International (ASTM). 2015. Standard Test Method
for Field Determination of Water Penetration of Installed
Exterior Windows, Skylights, Doors, and Curtain Walls,
by Uniform or Cyclic Static Air Pressure Difference. ASTM
E1105. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM.
2. ASTM. 2018. Standard Test Method for Field
Measurement of Air Leakage Through Installation
Exterior Windows and Doors. ASTM E783. West
Conshohocken, PA: ASTM.
3. International Code Council (ICC). 2021. 2021
International Existing Building Code. Washington,
DC: ICC.
4. ICC. 2021. 2021 International Energy Conservation
Code. Washington, DC: ICC.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Christopher N. Grey,
PE, joined Simpson
Gumpertz & Heger
(SGH) in 2011 and is
an associate principal
in SGH’s building
technology group in
Boston. His experience
includes investigating,
rehabilitating, and
designing building
enclosure systems
on a range of project types, from historic
buildings to contemporary high-rise structures.
He specializes in the design, construction
administration, and in-situ testing of building
enclosure systems, with a focus on design
efficiency, constructability, and performance.
Grey is a contributing member of the American
Architectural Manufacturer Associates. He has
served on several condominium boards and
consulted on many condominium restoration
projects, working directly for property
managers.
Kelsey A. Dunn,
PE, joined Simpson
Gumpertz & Heger
(SGH) in 2013
and is a senior
consulting engineer
in SGH’s building
technology
group.
Dunn’s experience
includes design,
investigation, testing,
and construction
administration
for existing building repairs,
restoration of historic structures, and new-design
building enclosures. She has consulted on many
condominium restoration projects.
Megan L. Wilson, PE,
joined SGH in 2018
and is a consulting
engineer in their
building technology
group in Boston.
Wilson has been
involved in a variety
of projects involving
design, investigation,
and construction
administration
for existing building repair projects,
rehabilitation of historic buildings, and
new-construction building enclosure consulting.
She has consulted on many condominium
restoration projects.
CHRISTOPHER N. GREY,
PE
KELSEY A. DUNN, PE
MEGAN L. WILSON,
PE
Please address reader comments to
chamaker@iibec.org, including
“Letter to Editor” in the subject line, or
IIBEC, IIBEC Interface,
434 Fayetteville St., Suite 2400,
Raleigh, NC 27601.
ASTRUT
Extruded Aluminum
Pipe Support protects roofs.
And pipes.
l One-piece design
l Integrated shallow strut allows
use of any standard accessory
l EPDM rubber pad helps protect roof
l Multiple, custom lengths—
cut-to-order from 6″ to 20″ long
l 150 lb. load; 5 lb. per square inch
compressive strength
Innovative rooftop supports since 1998
www.MAPAproducts.com
(903) 781-6996
The new A-Strut Aluminum
Pipe Supports from MAPA
elevate pipes above roofs,
protecting the roof from
abrasion and punctures, and
the pipes from deterioration
caused by movement and
rough roofing material.You’re
protected from headaches
and expenses.
TM
®
Model MA-6SF4-P
Patent Pending
February 2025 1151467_Editorial.indd 1 IIBEC Interf2a2c/01e/2 5 • 5 :3223ĐPM